In the case of Taylor v. Edri, 20 Fla. L. Weekly Supp. 727c (Broward Cnty. 2013), we learn valuable lessons on the importance of compliance with lease terms by both landlords and tenants and the correct procedures to follow when a tenant fails to pay the required monies to take occupancy. This case provides a roadmap for property managers on how to deal with tenant defaults effectively, ensuring legal protections are maintained and financial losses minimized.
Summary of the Case
The case revolves around a residential lease agreement for a property located in Hollywood, Florida. The tenant-plaintiffs, Dion and Sandesha Taylor, agreed to rent the property from the landlord-defendant, Nir Edri. As per the lease agreement, the tenants were required to pay a sum of $8,100, which included two months’ additional rent and a security deposit, before moving in. However, on the day of occupancy, the tenants arrived with only $5,400. The landlord, consequently, denied them occupancy for failing to pay the full amount required under the terms of the lease.
During the trial, it was established that the tenants breached the lease agreement by not tendering the full amount due. Moreover, they could not demonstrate that there was an anticipatory repudiation of the lease by the landlord. Despite this breach, the court found that they were still entitled to the return of their prepaid rent because the landlord failed to demonstrate that he met the conditions required under Florida Statute §83.595 for retaining the first month’s rent payment.
Key Takeaways for Property Managers
- Offer to Lease: it is important that the landlord provide the approved rental applicant (who is to become the tenant) with a formal, written offer to lease that contains the terms and conditions for the applicant to become a tenant and take occupancy of the premises. That way, if the applicant fails to comply with those terms and conditions, the applicant does not become a tenant of the premises. See our article on the Offer to Lease.
- Lease Compliance: It is crucial for property managers to ensure that all terms of the lease are clear and acknowledged by all parties. Tenants must be fully aware of their financial obligations before taking occupancy. Property managers should verify that tenants have paid all required monies as stipulated in the lease agreement before handing over possession of the property.
- Handling Tenant Defaults: In instances where a tenant does not pay all required monies to take occupancy:
- Immediate Communication: Communicate immediately with the tenant to understand their situation and attempt to resolve the shortfall.
- Documentation: Document all communications and keep records of any payments received and outstanding amounts.
- Legal Remedies: Understand and prepare to execute the remedy options under F.S. 83.595, which includes:
- Releasing the tenant from liability for any rent due.
- Holding the tenant liable for rent until the property is relet, using good faith and due diligence to re-rent.
- In case the property is relet, calculating the amount owed by the tenant on a pro-rata basis until the new tenant takes over.
- Florida Statute §83.595: This statute provides that if a tenant fails to fulfill their monetary obligations as stipulated in the lease, the landlord has options either to release them from the lease without further obligations or hold them liable until the property is leased again, or if there is a liquidated damages agreement, to charge the tenant that amount not to exceed 2 months’ rent amount. Property managers need to be familiar with this statute to handle early termination situations correctly.
- Prepaid Rent and Security Deposits: If a tenant defaults and possession is never transferred, the tenant is generally entitled to a refund of prepaid rents unless the landlord can justify their retention legally under F.S. 83.595 or pursuant to the Offer to Lease. Security deposits, however, must be handled according to state-specific laws regarding claims and notifications.
Navigating Tenant Payment Breaches
The case of Taylor v. Edri serves as a significant precedent for property managers dealing with tenant breaches related to financial obligations prior to taking occupancy. It underscores the necessity of adhering to statutory requirements and employing clear communication and documentation practices. By understanding and applying these principles, property managers can protect their interests and those of the property owners they represent, while ensuring fair and legal treatment of tenants.
Property Management Law Solutions, LLC is a Florida law firm that specializes in landlord-tenant law and is a landlord-only law firm. We provide statewide services including evictions, consultation plans, education and training, membership plans, lease agreement plans and more. If you are a landlord or property manager, contact us today or subscribe to one of our online membership plans.