A series of lawsuits has been filed by the families of three victims of gun violence at Cedar Grove Apartments, an affordable housing property in Miami Gardens, Florida. The lawsuits allege that negligent security measures by the property owners led to two deaths and one injury in 2023. The incidents include:
- January 4, 2023: A 27-year-old man visiting a friend was shot and killed. His family filed a lawsuit in March 2023.
- July 24, 2023: A 19-year-old resident was shot and killed. His family’s lease was terminated two days later, and they filed a lawsuit in October 2023.
- December 31, 2023: Another 19-year-old was shot and survived. He and his family filed a lawsuit in August 2024.
The property owners, Fairfield Cedar Grove LP and FF Properties LP, are associated with Fairfield Residential, a San Diego-based company managing over 42,700 units nationwide.
The lawsuits argue that the owners failed to provide adequate security measures, such as lighting, security cameras, and personnel, despite the property being in a high-crime area. The lawsuits also claim the owners had a duty to protect residents, visitors, and the public from criminal acts. The shootings are under investigation, and Fairfield Residential has not commented on the matter.
Legal Precedent
In a similar case, T.W. and K.W. v. Regal Trace, Ltd., 30 Fla. L. Weekly D1514a (4th DCA 2005), an important decision was made by the Florida Fourth District Court of Appeal, which examined the responsibilities of landlords in safeguarding tenants from foreseeable criminal activities. This case emphasizes the legal obligations that property owners and managers have in addressing tenant safety and the significant repercussions of failing to act on known or reasonably foreseeable threats.
Regal Trace Case Overview
T.W., a minor, was assaulted by Hassan Davis, a co-tenant at the Regal Trace apartment complex. Prior to the assault on T.W., Davis had lured another child, K.G., into a meter room on the premises and assaulted her. Regal Trace management was informed of the first incident through a tenant report and subsequent law enforcement contact but failed to issue any warnings to the community.
On the day of T.W.’s assault, she and her siblings were walking to school through an opening in the complex’s perimeter fence. Davis followed them, eventually isolating T.W. and committing the assault at an off-site abandoned building. The plaintiffs, T.W. and her mother, K.W., filed a lawsuit claiming that Regal Trace had failed in its duty to warn tenants about the earlier assault and prevent foreseeable harm.
The trial court initially granted summary judgment in favor of Regal Trace, stating no duty existed. However, on appeal, the Fourth District reversed this decision, recognizing that the landlord-tenant relationship created a duty to warn tenants of foreseeable risks.
Findings and Rulings
Duty to Warn Tenants
The court ruled that a landlord has a duty to warn tenants about known dangers on the premises if those dangers are foreseeable. The court recited landlord’s obligations in this manner:
“Where a defendant’s conduct creates a foreseeable zone of risk, the law generally will recognize a duty placed upon defendant either to lessen the risk or see that sufficient precautions are taken to protect others from the harm that the risk poses. However, a person or entity generally has no duty to take precautions to protect another against criminal acts of third parties. But, there is an exception to this rule where a special relationship, such as that between landlord and tenant exists. …A landlord has a duty to protect a tenant from reasonably foreseeable criminal conduct. However, in order to impose that duty an injured tenant must prove that the landlord has knowledge of prior similar criminal conduct occurring on the premises. (quotation marks and citations omitted).”
The landlord-tenant relationship is deemed a special relationship under law, which can impose a duty on the landlord to protect tenants of the potential for third-party criminal actions. The court noted that there are 3 factors that can create an obligation on the landlord “if, at the time of the injury, the [landlord] is in actual or constructive control of: 1. the instrumentality; 2. the premises on which the tort was committed; or 3. the tort-feasor”.
In this case, Regal Trace had control of the premises on which the assault took place and had knowledge of Davis’s prior assault but failed to communicate this risk to the community. The court recounted the records as follows:
“because [the landlord] admitted being told of the assault by a tenant and law enforcement, even if not told of the precise details of the assault. Because of Regal Trace’s knowledge that some sort of sexual assault had occurred against K.G. on its premises, likely by a tenant, and because it had a landlord-tenant relationship with T.W. and K.W., it had a duty to protect against the foreseeable criminal acts of third parties within the course of that special relationship, in this case by warning tenants about those foreseeable acts.”
In short, a warning about the previous assault could have allowed parents to take precautionary measures, such as supervising their children more closely or avoiding interactions with Davis. The court said,
“A full account of the assault on K.G. was not required to issue a basic warning about alleged criminal sexual activity presumably perpetrated by one tenant on a tenant child; knowledge that a tenant was targeting tenant children on the Regal Trace premises was sufficient for a reasonable apartment complex to recognize that its tenants would be exposed to risk if not warned.”
In addition, beyond the decision in Regal Trace, property managers should take action to terminate the tenancy of a tenant who commits a violent or sexual crime on the premises. Failing to enforce the tenant’s obligations in this regard can provide a basis for a victim to sue the property management company for failing to act to protect the resident community.
Lessons for Property Managers
These cases underscore critical lessons for property managers in ensuring tenant safety and mitigating liability:
- Act on Knowledge of Criminal Activity
- Property managers must take proactive steps when informed of criminal activities, particularly those posing ongoing risks. Ignoring such threats can result in legal liability if harm occurs to tenants.
- Implement Transparent Communication
- Effective communication is essential. Landlords should establish protocols for promptly notifying tenants about potential dangers, while balancing privacy concerns and law enforcement directives.
- Maintain Adequate Security Measures
- The existence of a gap in the perimeter fence allowed Davis to follow T.W. off the property. Regular inspections and maintenance of security infrastructure, such as fences, gates, lighting, and cameras, are crucial in preventing unauthorized access and ensuring tenant safety.
- Collaborate with Law Enforcement
- While landlords are not investigators, they must cooperate with law enforcement and clarify the boundaries of their responsibilities. Legal advice should guide actions when law enforcement discourages public disclosures.
- Educate Staff and Tenants
- Property managers should train staff to recognize and respond to potential threats. Tenant education programs can also increase community vigilance and foster a safer living environment.
- Develop Comprehensive Security Policies
- Establishing a formal security policy that includes reporting procedures, routine property assessments, and response plans for criminal incidents can protect both tenants and landlords from future risks.
Broader Implications for Landlords and Property Managers
The Regal Trace case highlights the standards of landlord liability concerning third-party criminal acts and their potential complexities. Courts increasingly recognize the landlord-tenant relationship as a special one, imposing heightened responsibilities on landlords to anticipate and address risks within their properties. Failure to fulfill these obligations can lead to severe legal and financial consequences.
Practical Recommendations for Property Managers
- Regular Risk Assessments
- Conduct periodic evaluations of the property’s security risks. This includes reviewing crime rates in the area and ensuring physical deterrents like locks, gates, and surveillance are operational.
- Incident Reporting System
- Establish a clear and accessible system for tenants to report suspicious activities or security concerns. Promptly address reports to demonstrate a commitment to tenant safety.
- Tenant Background Checks
- Implement rigorous screening processes to identify potential risks among prospective tenants. Ensure compliance with fair housing laws while prioritizing community safety.
- Community Engagement
- Foster a sense of community through tenant meetings or newsletters. Share safety tips and encourage tenants to look out for one another.
- Insurance and Legal Preparedness
- Maintain comprehensive liability insurance coverage to mitigate risks associated with tenant injuries or criminal activities. Regularly consult legal professionals to stay informed about evolving landlord responsibilities.
Tenant Safety & Legal Compliance
These cases serve as a pivotal reminder of the legal and moral duties property managers owe to their tenants. By taking proactive steps to ensure security and transparently addressing potential risks, landlords can not only protect their tenants but also safeguard themselves from liability. In an era of increasing scrutiny on tenant safety, adopting these measures is not just prudent but essential for sustainable property management.
Property Management Law Solutions, PLLC is a Florida law firm that specializes in landlord-tenant law and is a landlord-only law firm. We provide statewide services including evictions, consultation plans, education and training, membership plans, lease agreement plans and more. If you are a landlord or property manager, contact us today or subscribe to one of our online membership plans.