As a landlord, you may occasionally face new state or local regulations that affect the economic value of your rental property. It’s natural to feel frustrated when a regulation reduces the income you can generate, but it’s important to understand that such an impact does not automatically amount to a “taking” of your property by the government. The case ALA Mgmt. v. Hall Cnty., 24-10618 (11th Cir. Oct 09, 2024) provides insight into how courts approach this issue.
In this case, ALA Management owned a four-bedroom home in Hall County, Georgia, and sought to use it as a short-term rental property. When Hall County passed a new ordinance regulating short-term rentals, the property was subjected to inspection, which revealed that the septic system was only rated for one bedroom, not four. As a result, ALA Management was restricted to renting to fewer guests than anticipated, reducing the economic benefits of the property until they could upgrade the septic system. ALA Management claimed that the ordinance, by limiting their rental income, amounted to a regulatory taking under the Fifth Amendment of the United States Constitution.
The courts, however, disagreed. They held that just because the ordinance reduced the economic value of the property did not mean the government had taken the property. This case highlights several key factors landlords should consider when facing regulatory changes:
1. Economic Impact Is Only One Factor
When evaluating a potential regulatory taking, courts look at the economic impact of the regulation, but it is not the only factor. The reduction in value or profitability does not necessarily constitute a taking. In the ALA Management case, the property could still be used as a rental, albeit with a lower profit margin until the septic system was upgraded. Courts often find that regulations affecting profit potential, while frustrating, do not equate to a taking unless the property is deprived of all economically viable uses.
2. Investment-Backed Expectations
A court will also examine whether the regulation interferes with the property owner’s “investment-backed expectations.” In this case, ALA Management argued that it had expected to use the property as a four-bedroom rental, as it had historically been used. However, the court noted that a regulation that changes the owner’s ability to use a property exactly as they wish does not automatically invalidate those expectations. Landlords should be aware that just because a regulation alters the income potential of a property doesn’t mean it destroys legitimate expectations.
3. Character of the Government Action
The nature of governmental action also plays a role in determining whether a taking has occurred. In ALA Management, the court found that the ordinance served a legitimate public purpose—regulating septic systems for health and safety reasons. Regulations that adjust the economic benefits of a property in pursuit of a legitimate public goal, without appropriating the property or denying its basic use, are unlikely to be considered a taking.
The Legal Landscape of Property Regulations
It is essential for landlords to understand that regulations may negatively affect the economic value of a property, but these impacts alone do not usually rise to the level of a “taking” under the Fifth Amendment. Courts typically require a far more severe intrusion on property rights for such a claim to succeed. Staying informed about local laws and understanding the broader legal principles can help you navigate such changes while protecting your investment.
The case of ALA Management LLC v. Hall County serves as a reminder that, while regulations may impose burdens, they often do not equate to an unlawful government taking.
Property Management Law Solutions, LLC is a Florida law firm that specializes in landlord-tenant law and is a landlord-only law firm. We provide statewide services including evictions, consultation plans, education and training, membership plans, lease agreement plans and more. If you are a landlord or property manager, contact us today or subscribe to one of our online membership plans.