As an apartment manager, understanding the legal obligations regarding accessibility is crucial, especially when accommodating tenants with disabilities. One common request is the installation of a ramp in a common area. The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and the Fair Housing Act (FHA) provide clear guidelines about when landlords are required to make accommodations for disabled individuals, including when they must cover the cost of modifications like ramps. This article will outline when landlords are obligated to pay for such modifications and provide clarity on the intersection of the ADA and FHA in housing contexts.
ADA and Multifamily Housing
The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) primarily applies to “public accommodations” and commercial properties, but not directly to privately-owned residential apartment complexes. However, if parts of an apartment complex are open to the public—such as leasing offices, parking areas, and other common spaces—the ADA requires that these areas be accessible to individuals with disabilities. In these public areas, landlords must comply with ADA standards, which may include installing ramps or other accessibility features.
Fair Housing Act (FHA) and Reasonable Modifications
While the ADA covers public spaces, the Fair Housing Act (FHA) is more relevant to residential housing, including apartments. Under the FHA, tenants with disabilities have the right to request “reasonable modifications” to the apartment or its common areas to allow for equal enjoyment of the property. This includes the installation of ramps.
The FHA distinguishes between reasonable accommodations and reasonable modifications:
- Reasonable accommodations are changes in rules, policies, or practices to afford a disabled tenant equal opportunity to use and enjoy their dwelling (e.g., a reserved parking spot close to the entrance).
- Reasonable modifications are physical changes to the property to make it more accessible (e.g., adding a ramp, widening doorways, or installing grab bars).
While landlords are generally required to permit reasonable modifications, the responsibility for paying for these modifications varies depending on the type of building and the location of the requested change.
When Is the Landlord Obligated to Pay for a Ramp?
The obligation to pay for installing a ramp in a common area depends on several factors:
- Publicly Accessible Areas Under the ADA:
- If the ramp is requested in an area that is open to the public—such as the leasing office, parking lots, or walkways—the landlord is likely responsible for covering the cost. The ADA requires that these public spaces be accessible, and the landlord cannot pass on the cost of making these areas ADA-compliant to tenants.
- Example: A leasing office must be accessible to people with mobility issues. If the entrance to the office is up a set of stairs, the landlord is required to pay for the installation of a ramp.
- Private Residential Areas Under the FHA:
- If a disabled tenant requests a ramp to access a private residential area, like the entrance to their apartment, the tenant is typically responsible for the cost. However, the landlord must allow the modification, provided it is reasonable and does not impose an undue financial or administrative burden.
- Example: A tenant with mobility issues requests a ramp to enter the building from the parking lot, which is only used by residents. In this case, the landlord must allow the modification but is not required to pay for it.
- Federally Assisted Housing:
- In cases where the apartment complex receives federal funding, such as Section 8 housing, landlords may be required to pay for accessibility modifications, including ramps. Federal laws, like Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act, mandate that housing programs that receive federal financial assistance must provide equal access to persons with disabilities, which can include the installation of ramps at the landlord’s expense.
- State and Local Laws:
- In addition to the ADA and FHA, state and local laws may impose additional obligations on landlords. Some states have stricter accessibility requirements or provide funding or tax credits to landlords who make accessibility modifications.
Requirements for Modifications in Common Areas of Rentals
Under the FHA, if a tenant requests a modification in a common area, such as a lobby, laundry room, or sidewalk, the landlord is required to permit it, provided it is a reasonable modification. However, in most cases, the tenant is responsible for paying for the modification unless:
- The building is publicly accessible under the ADA.
- The building receives federal funding (under Section 504).
- State or local laws dictate otherwise.
If the tenant does pay for the modification, landlords can require that the modification be performed in a professional manner and according to building codes. In some instances, the landlord may ask the tenant to restore the area to its original condition when they move out, although this request is usually limited to interior modifications and not common area changes.
What Constitutes a “Reasonable” Modification?
A modification is considered “reasonable” if it:
- Is necessary for the tenant to fully enjoy the property.
- Does not impose an undue financial or administrative burden on the landlord.
- Does not fundamentally alter the nature of the housing operation.
For example, installing a ramp at the entrance of an apartment building is generally considered a reasonable modification. However, a tenant requesting extensive changes that significantly alter the property, or cost an exorbitant amount, may not be deemed reasonable.
Best Practices for Apartment Managers
As an apartment manager, you should handle modification requests with care to avoid potential legal pitfalls. Here are some best practices:
- Engage in an interactive process: If a tenant requests a modification, engage with them to understand their needs and find a mutually agreeable solution.
- Consult legal counsel: If you are unsure whether a modification is reasonable or who should pay for it, seek advice from legal professionals familiar with disability law.
- Understand your property’s status: Determine whether your property falls under ADA regulations (for public spaces) or FHA standards, and if any state or local laws apply.
- Document the process: Keep thorough records of all tenant requests and your responses to ensure compliance with federal and local laws.
Conclusion
In summary, the responsibility of paying for a ramp in an apartment complex’s common areas depends on whether the area is publicly accessible and whether the housing receives federal assistance. Under the ADA, landlords are typically responsible for ensuring accessibility in public areas, while under the FHA, tenants are usually responsible for paying for modifications that affect private or residential areas. By understanding these laws, apartment managers can ensure compliance while maintaining a positive relationship with tenants.
Property Management Law Solutions, LLC is a Florida law firm that specializes in landlord-tenant law and is a landlord-only law firm. We provide statewide services including evictions, consultation plans, education and training, membership plans, lease agreement plans and more. If you are a landlord or property manager, contact us today or subscribe to one of our online membership plans.